Okay you all, be careful what you wish for! (In response to the question of how we implement dictation), here is a VERY detailed breakdown of what we do. I pray it is not utterly overwhelming, and I promise, it likely takes us less time to do, than it will take you to read through it all. Feel free to ask questions, I love dictation and Language Arts! (I even pulled my dyslexic high schooler BACK to dictation this year, and she’s actually been loving it and is encouraged by the progress she is seeing in her spelling).
What we Do:
• On Monday, I choose a dictation selection from their copywork/reading passage that is a good length for that particular student or class, and includes some challenging or new words. (Focus on quality over quantity, and don’t worry about starting with simply a short sentence and building up from there… You will be surprised at how much they can progress in a year). I usually choose these passages (or sentences) in advance when I make our LA Lesson Books, though I may shorten them as needed (in which case I’d highlight or star the portion we’ll be focusing on). I like to cover a mix of styles throughout the year (prose, poetry, literature, nonfiction, etc. as well as a variety of punctuation), and have the passages be at or near their reading/spelling level (which is why I’ve historically used mostly the McGuffey’s Readers, though any sources could be utilized). *Example LA Lesson Book: Fifth Reader
• I read the passage to them clearly and carefully, so they can hear proper pronunciation, cadence, etc., as well as “hear” the punctuation (we often discuss how punctuation is simply there to make a jumble of words sound clear or lovely, and enable them to be communicated effectively and well).
• I then underline any words that deserve some attention for us to copy over to our spelling table. This will vary by student. Some want a thorough list of any words that might possibly catch them up, others prefer one that’s more pared down and not overwhelming.
• Then either I or the student copy those words over to the first column of our spelling table (in my classroom, I’d write the list of words on the board and they’d copy them).
• We quickly discuss any interesting patterns or considerations (both from the list and the passage at large). Usually underlining common blends, shared patterns from our list, noting words that are interesting or aren’t pronounced or spelled how one might expect, chatting about any synonyms/homonyms, asking them to clarify contractions, their/there, defining unfamiliar words, discussing a poem’s unique punctuation, and so on. Breaking longer words into syllables so they can clearly hear the different parts: “clap-ping” …can you hear those two Ps?” etc. Nothing long or formal, and the purpose isn’t to dissect and strip apart every word, but to give the passage and its words/punctuation our full attention and have a conversation about them.
• For the next 2-3 days they focus on that selection by reading the full dictation passage to me carefully EACH day and paying attention to the punctuation (NOT just focusing on their list of spelling words), working on their copywork (that includes this dictation selection), and working on their spelling table.
• Spelling Table specifics: I encourage them to look at each word, take a “mental picture of it” in their head, close their eyes and try to picture it, then cover it up and write it down in the column next to it (then checking it and correcting it right away, if needed).
• Our personal rhythm has been to do a quick oral “spelling bee” on Wednesday where I call out words and they either write them on their drawing boards or spell them to me orally (they usually find this enjoyable). On Thursday, we do a practice dictation (with the whole passage either on their drawing board or sheet of paper), and on Friday we do a final dictation. If they complete an excellent dictation on Thursday, I let them count that as their final.
• Final dictation specifics: When they are ready, I read our selection through slowly, pausing as needed in between sentences (ideally at punctuation breaks, though oftentimes I need to break it up smaller). Once finished, I read the whole thing through, asking them to double-check and make any desired edits to spelling, capitalization, etc. (I know it is often suggested not to repeat at all, but I do at the end, and do not think it has been detrimental). The length they will be able to dictate at a time will grow over the year, no need to make it needlessly onerous.
Once finished and they are satisfied with their work, I collect, and make necessary corrections right away (usually fully erasing or crossing out any mistakes). When I am doing this in a class that requires grades, when grading later I would highlight the incorrect words or punctuation, and take a picture for the parents before fully crossing out the mistakes before handing back. We don’t want students getting the misspelled words stuck in their head. At home I usually erase the incorrect word or punctuation, then give it back to them right away to correct.
————————————————————————
I realize this probably sounds like overkill when listed out fully in detail, but many of these steps truly just take a few minutes! There is much nuance as well. We tend to establish this rhythm to mitigate against inattention or struggling spellers, and then I adjust at my discretion to individual students. Sometimes I can tell a student is fully ready for their dictation and I skip steps. Sometimes we have a busy day and I intentionally choose to skip something. But I have found this rhythm to generally work very well whether with strong spellers, weak spellers, dyslexic spellers, and most everything in between. I have always observed improvement.
Dictation is such phenomenal tool, and helps with spelling, punctuation, penmanship, etc. all in one. I have noticed it really helps them spell words in context, while in previous years (using other curricula at school), I would see a student spell something correctly on a spelling test, then immediately misspell it in subsequent writing.